The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of ICC Academy or ICC.
Trade finance compliance is increasingly recognised as an integral part of the transaction itself, rather than a back-office control applied around it.
A trade finance transaction can involve parties in different jurisdictions, with goods moving across borders and banks becoming involved at different stages. The position is not necessarily fixed once the transaction has been agreed. Terms may be amended or shipping arrangements changed. Information appearing later, including in the documents presented, may also reveal circumstances that were not apparent at the outset. The compliance position can therefore change as the transaction develops.
This helps explain why international trade remains attractive to those seeking to disguise financial crime. The enormous volume of legitimate trade provides an environment in which illicit value can potentially be concealed, particularly where transactions are complex or information is fragmented between different parties.
For the practitioner, trade finance compliance therefore begins with understanding the trade. KYC in trade finance establishes what should reasonably be expected from the customer. Sanctions compliance controls consider whether restrictions affect the parties or the transaction, while financial crime risk controls look for activity that may be using legitimate trade to disguise another purpose. They are different disciplines, but in practice the information arising from one frequently affects the others.
In brief:
- KYC in trade finance, sanctions compliance, and financial crime monitoring are increasingly connected disciplines, not separate checks.
- Compliance risk isn’t fixed at the outset: new information in shipping documents, ownership structures or sanctions designations can change the picture as a deal develops.
- A risk-based approach to trade finance compliance means recognising when something warrants closer review, not diagnosing financial crime outright.
Know Your Customer (KYC) in trade finance
KYC in trade finance differs considerably from the more straightforward customer identification that may be associated with retail banking.
Why KYC in trade finance goes beyond customer identification
Knowing who holds an account is no longer sufficient in trade finance. The bank needs to understand what the customer does and how it normally trades, building a picture of the business against which individual transactions can be considered. That understanding becomes more difficult in international trade, where the relationship often extends beyond the immediate customer to agents or intermediaries, while cross-border corporate structures can make it less straightforward to establish who ultimately owns or controls a party involved in the transaction.
Customer due diligence, or CDD, provides the starting point by establishing who the customer is and, where appropriate, who ultimately owns or controls it, but in trade finance it also needs to provide an understanding of the relationship and the trading activity the bank can reasonably expect to see.
When EDD is warranted
Enhanced due diligence, or EDD, comes into play where the assessed risk warrants closer examination, perhaps because the ownership structure is difficult to understand or because something within the transaction represents a significant departure from the customer’s established activity. A move into a higher-risk jurisdiction could prompt that closer examination, as could a change in the nature of the goods being traded or the appearance of an unfamiliar intermediary whose commercial role is unclear.
Keeping customer understanding continuous
For example, a company that has historically imported consumer products from established suppliers might suddenly request financing for high-value industrial machinery purchased through a newly introduced intermediary. There may be an entirely legitimate commercial reason for the change, but it would be reasonable for the bank to understand that reason before relying upon its existing view of the customer. This illustrates why KYC in trade finance increasingly needs to be continuous rather than something established at the outset and periodically revisited: information obtained when the relationship begins provides the baseline, while subsequent trading activity either supports that understanding or indicates that it needs to change.
Sanctions compliance in trade finance
Sanctions screening is highly visible within trade finance, but checking names against sanctions lists addresses only part of the risk.
Ownership and control can be as important as the name appearing on a document. An entity may not itself be designated but can still be affected because of its relationship with a sanctioned person or company.
Trade finance introduces further considerations because sanctions risk can arise from the physical trade as well as from the parties involved. A vessel identified in a bill of lading may require investigation, while the routing of the shipment can create concerns that were not apparent when the transaction was agreed. The goods themselves may also require closer attention because of their specification or intended use, with dual-use goods providing an obvious example of the difficulty.
A trade finance practitioner cannot be expected to determine complex export-control classifications from personal knowledge, but a vague description of technically sophisticated equipment being shipped to a sensitive destination may justify further enquiry and, where appropriate, referral to specialists.
Why sanctions requirements differ between banks
The position is complicated further by the absence of a single international sanctions regime. UN sanctions may provide an international foundation, but individual jurisdictions impose their own measures, which are not necessarily aligned. The institutions participating in the same transaction may therefore face different legal requirements, while an individual bank may adopt a risk appetite that goes beyond what the law strictly prohibits. The willingness of one institution to process a transaction consequently provides no assurance that another will be able, or willing, to do the same.
These issues become particularly visible in documentary trade because information available when a credit is issued may be supplemented by what subsequently appears in the documents.
Sanctions compliance in trade finance vs documentary compliance
A documentary credit covering machinery might initially present no apparent sanctions concern, yet the bill of lading presented later could identify a vessel requiring investigation or reveal a routing that was not apparent from the application. This does not necessarily affect the documentary status of the presentation, and it is important to maintain the distinction: documentary examination determines compliance with the credit and the applicable rules, whereas sanctions controls address whether the bank can proceed with the transaction. A sanctions concern should therefore not be converted into an artificial documentary discrepancy simply because it emerges during examination.
Nor is the sanctions position fixed for the life of the transaction. A designation or other regulatory change after issuance may affect a transaction that was considered acceptable at the outset, potentially while the goods are already moving or before payment becomes due. Screening and sanctions compliance assessment therefore needs to continue as the transaction develops rather than being treated as a control completed at the beginning.
Financial crime risk and trade-based money laundering (TBML)
How trade-based money laundering works
Trade-based money laundering can be particularly difficult to identify because the underlying trade may be genuine. As recognised by the Financial Action Task Force, legitimate trade transactions can be used to disguise criminal proceeds and move value, without necessarily relying upon fabricated documents or fictitious shipments.
Real goods may pass between genuine companies while the manipulation takes place within the commercial terms of the transaction, with over-invoicing providing a straightforward example: goods worth substantially less might be invoiced at USD 500,000, allowing excess value to be transferred through what appears to be an ordinary trade payment. The same principle can operate in reverse through under-invoicing.
Recognising financial crime risk in trade finance in context
The indicators encountered by trade practitioners are often less obvious and need to be understood in context. Goods appearing on an invoice may sit uncomfortably with what is known about the customer’s business, while quantities or prices may be difficult to reconcile with the apparent commercial purpose of the trade. None of this establishes financial crime, since an unusual price may have a perfectly reasonable commercial explanation and differences in terminology can arise during an entirely legitimate transaction.
The practitioner’s role is therefore not to treat the unfamiliar as suspicious, but to recognise when the available information no longer provides a convincing commercial explanation and further enquiry is justified.
Why TBML is hard to detect
The scale of international commerce makes this particularly challenging, providing an enormous volume of legitimate activity within which illicit value can potentially be concealed. Pricing is not always readily verifiable, especially for specialised goods, while no single institution involved in the transaction may have access to every piece of information needed to understand the complete trade. Automated monitoring can help identify patterns or anomalies across large volumes of activity, but transaction-level awareness remains important because it is often the practitioner who sees something that does not fit comfortably with what is already known about the customer.
A documentary credit transaction, for example, might reveal a value markedly different from the customer’s previous trading activity, or the documents might introduce a counterparty whose involvement was not apparent when the transaction began. The issue is not whether either observation establishes TBML, but whether it creates sufficient reason, when considered alongside what is already known about the customer and the trade, to seek an explanation.
A risk-based approach to trade finance compliance
Connecting KYC, sanctions, and TBML controls
KYC, sanctions controls and financial crime monitoring are most effective when they form part of a continuing risk-based approach rather than operate as separate compliance exercises.
The understanding developed during onboarding provides the context against which subsequent trading activity can be considered, but that understanding inevitably develops as the relationship progresses. A proposed transaction may raise questions that were not apparent from the original customer information, while documents presented later can reveal circumstances that were not known when the trade was first considered. An amendment to a documentary credit might similarly change the nature of the transaction and with it the risk assessment.
What is learned through this activity should, in turn, inform the bank’s developing understanding of the customer, particularly where trading behaviour begins to move away from what had previously been regarded as normal.
The role of technology and AI in compliance
Information therefore needs to follow the transaction rather than being confined to individual compliance checks, and technology is making it increasingly possible to connect information that might previously have remained fragmented.
Automated screening can process large volumes of transaction data efficiently, while more sophisticated monitoring can identify patterns across a customer’s activity that may warrant attention. Artificial intelligence potentially takes this further by recognising relationships across transactions that might not be immediately apparent to an individual practitioner, although identifying an anomaly is not the same as explaining it.
The significance of what has been identified still has to be understood within the commercial context of the particular trade, leaving professional judgement central to the process.
Building trade finance compliance expertise
Trade finance compliance is consequently becoming part of the professional skill set expected of practitioners, without requiring them to become sanctions lawyers or financial crime investigators. Specialist expertise will continue to be essential, but it cannot replace the awareness needed by those handling the transaction, particularly when they may be the first to encounter information that does not fit comfortably with what is already known about the customer or the underlying trade.
The practitioner therefore needs sufficient knowledge to recognise when closer examination is warranted, whether that leads to enhanced due diligence or the involvement of compliance specialists. This is the environment reflected in the new compliance module within the Certified Trade Finance Professional programme, recognising that compliance can no longer be separated from the technical knowledge needed to handle trade finance effectively. Both ultimately depend upon the same fundamental capability: understanding the transaction.